Comment #: CA52023
Rating:1.0
Comments:
Judge Carmen Luege is extremely incompetent, bias, and shows extreme favoritism in what strongly appeared to be pre-determined rulings. She also blatantly, ignored the law, facts, substantial evidence, and the merits of the case; beside the fact that my ex. and his lawyer, are pathological liars and no better, than common criminals.

Judge Luege was transferred from the civil division to the Family Law Division 1-1/2 years ago. It is very obvious that she knew very little about family law, knew very little about the case at hand, along with absolute cluelessness, about the facts and evidence, in front of her. None of this seemed to matter, since she had already, strongly appeared, to have made up her mind, before we even entered the courtroom.

The funny thing is she claims to come in on the weekends to read all of her pleadings before hearings. You will find this to be false as she knows absolutely nothing about the parties. In fact, there was a police officer that came in front of her for a divorce, she was admonishing him and did not even know he was a high ranking Sergeant for the Orange County Sheriff's Department.

Comment #: CA51471
Rating:2.0
Comments:
She is extremely biased in favor of consumers, and has shown this inclination time and again. Instant 170.6.

Comment #: CA49431
Rating:1.0
Comments:
She doesn't care about the child's best interest. She knows nothing of family law. She is absolutely bias and just awful.

Comment #: CA49154
Rating:1.0
Comments:
This judge accepted only one party's evidence and not the others. She also overlooked contempt of court from respondent as the respondent withheld children for over 3 months with zero contact to the petitioning coparent. Respondent claimed the petiotioner was late picking up their children when in the original court order it stated that respondent was supposed to be dropping them off to petiotioner. The children have been affected by all this and are afraid that it will happen again. There is currently a petition on Facebook against this judge from a different party and source because others have had the same horrible experience with this Judge. Please help and spread the word.

Comment #: CA49104
Rating:1.0
Comments:
This judge accepted only one party's evidence and not the others. She also overlooked contempt of court from respondent as the respondent withheld children for over 3 months with zero contact to the petitioning coparent. Respondent claimed the petiotioner was late picking up their children when in the original court order it stated that respondent was supposed to be dropping them off to petiotioner. The children have been affected by all this and are afraid that it will happen again. There is currently a petition on Facebook against this judge from a different party and source because others have had the same horrible experience with this Judge. Please help and spread the word.

Comment #: CA46726
Rating:1.0
Comments:
Absolutely horrible, not fare, doesn’t really know FAMILY Law.
Does not follow THERAPISTS recommendations!
Should be fired!!!
She has such approach that will eventually make children mentally unstable because of her poor judgement.