Hon. Betty Owen Stinson See Rating Details

Supreme Court (Civil)
Bronx County
See Comments

Attorney Average Rating:   3.5 - 5 rating(s)
Non-Attorney Average Rating:   1.0 - 3 rating(s)
Please send me alerts on this judge
E-mail Address:




Add your own rating

E-Mail Address (will not be displayed)
   
Confirm E-mail Address      
Zip
Occupation

Only items marked with (*) are averaged into the displayed overall rating.


General Rating Criteria

* Temperament (1=Awful,10=Excellent)
* Scholarship (1=Awful,10=Excellent)
* Industriousness (1=Not at all industrious,10=Highly industrious)
* Ability to Handle Complex Litigation (1=Awful,10=Excellent)
* Punctuality (1=Chronically Late,10=Always on Time)
* General Ability to Handle Pre-Trial Matters (1=Not all Able, 10=Extremely Able)
* General Ability as a Trial Judge (1=Not all Able, 10=Extremely Able)
Flexibility In Scheduling (1=Completely Inflexible,10=Very Flexible)


Criminal Rating Criteria (if applicable)

* Evenhandedness in Criminal Litigation (1=Demonstrates Bias,10=Entirely Evenhanded)
General Inclination Regarding Bail (1=Pro-Defense,10=Pro-Government)
Involvement in Plea Discussions (1=Not at all Involved, 10=Very Involved)
General Inclination in Criminal Cases Pretrial Stage (1=Pro-prosecution,10=Pro-defense)
General Inclination in Criminal Cases Trial Stage (1=Pro-prosecution,10=Pro-defense)
General Inclination in Criminal Cases Sentencing Stage (1=Pro-prosecution,10=Pro-defense)


Civil Rating Criteria (if applicable)

* Evenhandedness in Civil Litigation (1=Not at all Evenhanded,10=Entirely Evenhanded)
Involvement in Settlement Discussions (1=Not at all Involved,10=Very Involved)
General Inclination (1=Pro-defendant, 10=Pro-plaintiff)
Comments




What others have said about Hon. Betty Owen Stinson


Comments


Other

Comment #: NY8408
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
Comment #: NY8383
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
Comment #: NY8377
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
Comment #: NY8369
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
Comment #: NY8339
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
Listen to WHAT my son RICARDO JOSE RIVERA says about his biological dad...we got AWAY from him UNTIL JUDGE BETTY OWEN STINSON BROUGHT HIM BACK INTO OUR LIVES and now my son is DEAD!!!

https://youtu.be/AH0YpXfL4W0

JUDGE STINSON DOES NOT BELONG ON THE BENCH.

THIS PAGE HAS DELETED MANY REVIEWS BY LAWYERS THAT EXPOSED THIS JUDGE; I WISH THEY WOULD KEEP REPOSTING THEM OR REPORT HER TO THE NYS BAR ASSOCIATION!

I WISH A *FEDERAL PROSECUTOR* WOULD INVESTIGATE THIS JUDGE & PUT HER BEHIND FEDERAL PRISON BARS WHERE SHE BELONGS; IN MY OPINION!!!!!!!!!!!!
*REPOSTING - WAS DELETED*

Criminal Defense Lawyer

Comment #: NY8407
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
Comment #: NY8382
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
Comment #: NY8376
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
Comment #: NY8368
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
Comment #: NY8338
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
Pg 2 of 2


DOCTOR DRESSLER AT JMC ALSO SAID MY SON HAD KIDNEY FAILURE WHEN THE MEDICAL DIRECTOR OF MY SON'S INSURANCE COMPANY DISCOVERED THAT WAS A LIE; MY SON HAD PERFECT KIDNEYS. ALSO THE COURTS SAID MY SON HAD NO HEALTH CARE PROXY AND THAT WAS A LIE; I WAS MY SON'S HEALTH CARE PROXY ALONG WITH A GOOD FRIEND OF MY SON AND I.

This JUDGE came against me for trying to get my son (with my son's Insurance company) OUT OF JACOBI MEDICAL CENTER and to a better hospital in Manhattan and because of my Christian faith; she SLANDERED my name and took my son out of my life FOREVER - in my opinion she is RESPONSIBLE FOR MY SON'S PAIN AND SUFFERING AND DEATH !!!


*I CAN KEEP REPOSTING WHEN YOU DELETE*

WHAT YOU SHOULD DELETE IS JUDGE STINSON'S FALSE REVIEW THAT SHE GAVE HERSELF SAYING THAT SHE IS A GREAT AND LEARNED JUDGE; THAT IS NOT WHAT ALL THE LAWYERS SAY IN REVIEWS IN HERE - THAT YOU ALSO DELETED !!!
*REPOSTING - HAD BEEN DELETED*

Other

Comment #: NY8406
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
Comment #: NY8381
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
Comment #: NY8375
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
Comment #: NY8367
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
Comment #: NY8337
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
Pg 1 of 2

https://www.youtube.com/shared?ci=0pt1qhNQYZU

Unhonorable Judge Betty Owen Stinson SHOULD BE REMOVED FROM THE BENCH.

This judge took my son's rights away WITHOUT DUE PROCESS when he was only at JACOBI MEDICAL CENTER with a passing gall stone and made my son's ESTRANGED biological dad GUARDIAN (my son had no contact with that man since he was 15 years of age) whom we had a FINAL JUDGEMENT from Florida the man could NOT even talk to my son without my son's permission. A man that was arrested for child abuse on my son and the Courts in Florida allowed my son and I to leave Florida and move to NY to get away from him.

Judge Stinson has SHAM HEARINGS and ruins people's lives; because of her my son suffered for FOUR YEARS and separated from his family (not allowed mail, phone calls or visits) ABUSED, NEGLECTED & DRUGGED TO DEATH.

Judge Stinson did not allow my son his own attorney; she assigned corrupt Court appointed attorney's that MISREPRESENTED my son and they ALL should be DISBARRED.

THIS JUDGE IS A DISGRACE TO THE JUDICIAL SYSTEM; she was found QUILTY OF MISCONDUCT IN FLORIDA and accused of CORRUPTION in the Bronx and SHE IS STILL ON THE BENCH IN BRONX NY - WHY?

My 31 year young son RICARDO JOSE RIVERA is DEAD because of her; Mr. Richmond had a hospital do a DNR on my son - a son he hated and abused as a child - Mr. Richmond an alcoholic, child abuser, narcissist - psychopath.

I raised my son and he was my life and she had him taken out of my life and will face God for what she did.

My son spent the end of his life ISOLATED from those he loved and those that loved him.

I am THANKFUL I got to see my son ten days before they DID NOT RESUSCITATE my son after they allegedly overdosed him and RICHARD RANDALL RICHMOND (Judge Stinson made guardian) ordered DNR. The first time I had seen him in six months. Prior to that LAST visit; I only saw my son at Court hearings in Massachusetts my former husband and nursing home Mr. Richmond put my son in; approximately 7 times BEFORE HONORABLE JUDGES IN MASSACHUSETTS that DENIED GIVING MY SON ANTIPSYCHOTIC DRUGS because my son was COMPETENT and NEVER had any mental health issues.

MY SON NEVER NEEDED A GUARDIAN; MY SON WAS ONLY IN A HOSPITAL FOR A PASSING GALL STONE THAT PASSED - HE HAD TRANSVERSE MYELITIS THAT JMC CALLED A MENTAL HEALTH CONDITION - AFTER THIS JUDGE TOOK MY SON'S RIGHTS AWAY AND JMC MISDIAGNOSED MY SON I CONTACTED THE NYS ATTORNEY GENERAL'S PATIENT ABUSE UNIT AND AN MMPI WAS DONE ON MY SON SHOWING MY SON HAD NO MENTAL HEALTH ISSUES. THIS JUDGE WOULD NOT ACCEPT THE TRUTH AND ADHERE TO MOTIONS FILED THAT MR. RICHMOND HAD A CRIMINAL HISTORY THAT MADE HIM UNQUALIFIED TO BE GUARDIAN; SHE WAS BIAS TOWARDS MY CHRISTIAN FAITH AND I BELIEVE SHE WAS PROBABLY GETTING KICK BACKS FROM JACOBI MEDICAL CENTER TO COVER UP THEIR MISDIAGNOSE THAT LEAD MY SON TO BE PARTIALLY PARALYZED!!!

I hope someday this Judge ends up in a NURSING HOME and is treated the way she allowed my son to be treated.

My son died on September 27, 2015 - I had to find out on my own the following month; he was creamated without my knowledge (we buried a lock of hair and baby tooth because the Court will not tell me where my son's remains are) with a FRAUDULENT DEATH CERTIFICATE that has the name RICHARD RICHMOND on it and since my former husband stole my son's identity.

THIS JUDGE NOT ONLY SHOULD BE REMOVED FROM THE BENCH, DISBARRED ALONG WITH CORRUPT COURT APPOINTED ATTORNEY'S BUT GO TO PRISON - IN MY OPINION!
*REPOSTING - WAS DELETED*

Other

Comment #: NY8405
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
http://www.therobingroom.com/newyork/RatingSubmitted.aspx



https://youtu.be/qLLv_GBVg6U


CORRUPT - EVIL JUDGE BETTY OWEN STINSON CHANGED THE DATE OF THE HEARING TO THE DATE OF MY MOTHER'S FUNERAL - THINKING I WOULD NOT ATTEND THE HEARING - SHE SOMEHOW GOT MY ESTRANGED FORMER HUSBAND TO A MEETINGS WITH HER IN A CONFERENCE ROOM AT JACOBI MEDICAL CENTER FOR OVER 30 MINUTES BEFORE MY SON AND I EVEN KNEW MR. RICHMOND WAS IN NY. HOW UNETHICAL IS THAT? VERY UNETHICAL! AND A CHILD ABUSER! THE COURT APPOINTED ATTORNEY NEVER EVEN TOLD MY SON UNTIL RIGHT BEFORE WE WENT INTO THE SHAM HEARING -- THAT EVENTUALLY COST MY YOUNG SON HIS LIFE. I HAVE HUNDREDS OF VIDEOS (MULTIPLE PEOPLE NOW HAVE COPIES OF EVERYTHING) MY SON'S STORY WILL BE TOLD INTERNATIONALLY - FOR THE WORLD TO KNOW WHAT THIS JUDGE DID !!!

AND... SOMEONE IS WRITING A BOOK AND ANOTHER PERSON DOCUMENTARY FILM.

SOMEDAY THIS JUDGE (WITH OR WITHOUT ME) WILL BE PUT TO SHAME FOR CAUSING MY SON SO MUCH PAIN AND ENDING HIS YOUNG LIFE AND SEPARATING MY SON AND I.

I HAVE BEEN WATCHING VIDEOS TONIGHT OF THE SUFFERING MY SON WENT THROUGH BECAUSE OF THIS JUDGE - THERE HAS TO BE SOME ACCOUNTABILITY - OBVIOUSLY SHE HAS NO CONSCIENCE.

I JUST WONDER WHAT SHE GAINED FROM IT ALL? MONEY - KICKBACKS?

I BELIEVE MY SON'S PRAYERS WOULD HAVE BEEN ANSWERED HAD I NOT BEEN THREATENED OUTSIDE THE CONFERENCE ROOM BEFORE GOING IN; THEREFORE, TELLING MY SON TO STIPULATE UNTIL WE HAD SOME TIME TO FIGURE OUT WHAT TO DO. I WAS TOLD OUTSIDE THE CONFERENCE ROOM BY CORRUPT COURT ATTORNEY YOU HAD WORKING FOR YOU AND JMC - I BETTER STIPULATE BECAUSE JUDGE STINSON TOLD HER TO TELL ME SHE HAD BEEN TAKING TO MR. RICHMOND (PRIVATELY) AND SHE LIKED HIM AND DID NOT LIKE ME (SHE DID NOT EVEN KNOW ME) AND IF I DID NOT MY SON WOULD BE SENT TO AN END OF LIFE FACILITY AND WARD OF THE STATE AND **NEVER** SEE MY SON AGAIN **THAT DAY** GIVE ME A LIE DETECTOR TEST - I WILL PASS. GIVE STINSON & COURT APPOINTED ATTORNEY A LIE DETECTOR TEST AND THEY WILL FAIL. I OBVIOUSLY STIPULATED UNDER DURESS AND CONVINCED MY SON TO STIPULATE.

HOWEVER IMMEDIATELY AFTER SEVERAL MOTIONS WERE FILED (BEFORE STINSON SIGNED AN ORDER) RICKY CHANGED HIS MIND - MR RICHMOND THREATHS TO USE HIS POWER TO INSTITUTIONALIZE MY SON FOR EVER THAT CHANGED TO BIGGER THREATS HE WAS GOING TO DIE (RICKY) AS IF MR. RICHMOND HAS THE POWER TO DO IT..THE MAN WAS CRAZY. I GUESS JUDGE STINSON IS TOO OR THE DEVIL IN DISGUISE.

JUDGE STINSON SEENED TO **ENJOY** MY SON'S SUFFERING AS MUCH AS MR. RICHMOND DID - THEY BOTH BELONG IN PRISON - AND BOTH ALLOWED ME TO GO ON NOT EVEN KNOWING MY SON DIED AND WITH A FRAUDULENT DEATH CERTIFICATE AND NO BODY OR ASHES. ALL I CAN SAY IS THIS WOMAN IN MY OPINION IS A VERY SICK IN THE MIND OR EVIL WOMAN.

SOMEDAY I CAN PROMISE YOU THE WORLD WILL SEE THESE VIDEOS AND PICTURES I AM LOOKING AT TONIGHT (MANY HAVE COPIES OF IT ALL IN CASE ANYTHING HAPPENS TO ME) AND I HOPE A FEDERAL PROSECUTOR PUTS HER BEHIND BARS - IF NOT THERE IS A CELL WAITING FOR HER IN HELL.

THERE MAY BE A SHORTER FILM COMING OUT FIRST - MAYBE SOONER THAN SHE THINKS...THE BOOK IS ALREADY BEING WRITTEN BY A VERY TALENTED YOUNG WOMEN (WHY I TOOK DOWN MY SOCIAL MEDIA ACCOUNTS AND BLOGS; SO THE STORY CAN BE PROFESSIONALLY TOLD)...AND JUDGE STINSON CAN NO LONGER ABUSE HER POWER WITH ME - NOR SILENCE MY SON (ON HUNDREDS OF VIDEOS & PICTURES NEVER SHARED ON THE INTERNET) AND NOT BE ABLE TO **DELETE** AS SHE HAS EVERY BAD REVIEW IN HERE ON HER **DELETED** AND ONLY ONE GOOD REVIEW SHE PROBABLY DID HERSELF.

SHAME ON WHOEVER WORKS FOR THIS JUDGE AND ASSISTS HER; DO YOU EVER THINK WHAT IF THAT WAS YOUR CHILD OR LOVED ONE?????

NO WONDER HER AND RICHARD RANDALL RICHMOND GOT ALONG SO GOOD; THEY ARE **BOTH** NARCISSIST PSYCHOPATHS IN MY OPINION !!!

I AM JUST GLAD MY SON LOVED JESUS CHRIST YESHUA SO MUCH; RICKY IS SAFE FROM THE TWO OF YOU AND ALL ELSE YOU **ALLOWED** TO HURT AND KILL MY SON....HOW DO YOU SLEEP AT NIGHT????

Litigant

Comment #: NY7641
Rating:1.0
Comments:
I agree with the comment just posted in regards to Judge Stinson being one of the two mentioned: a sociopath or psychopath: key traits being that sociopaths and psychopaths have some things in common and anyone that works with Judge Stinson or been in her Court room KNOW she has such traits.

A disregard for laws and social mores
A disregard for the rights of others
A failure to feel remorse or guilt
A tendency to display violent behavior

I just think she needs to get to the root of her issues. Did something happen to her as a child or teenager? Did a twenty some year marriage and adopted children not fullfil her needs? Does she have insecurity issues; and instead of taking care of her appearance she bullies people?

If she does not want to accept her condition and get help, no one can help her. However, this women's mental state adversely effects her decision making.

Other

Comment #: NY7377
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
I am in agreement with all the ones deleted as well as the two below.

Other

Comment #: NY7318
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
I AM IN AGREEMENT WITH THE POST BELOW!

Criminal Defense Lawyer

Comment #: NY7229
Rating:Not Rated
Comments:
Comment #: NY7227
Rating:Rated #1
Comments: Revised
I was wondering how Justice Betty Owen-Stinson established a 3.5 rating; until I noticed many criminal lawyer's rated her with one star, that lead their rating to be deleted.
Who is responsible for the deletions in here? It certainly reflects badly on the entire Supreme Court in the Bronx. May the new year bring back integrity to the bench, that this judge took away from it.

Litigant

Comment #: NY7160
Rating:1.0
Comments:
She is a shill for the defense bar. Plaintiff attorneys get hammered before her regularly.

Criminal Defense Lawyer

Comment #: NY7148
Rating:1.0
Comments:
Criminal Defense Lawyer
Comment #: NY7142
Rating:1.0
Comments:
Comment #: NY7137
Rating:1.0
Comments:
In a civil case the burden of proof is by a preponderence of the evidence, while in a criminal case the state's persuasion burden is met only by proof beyond a reasonable doubt 397 U.S. 358, 361. Lugubriously enough in Justice Owen-Stinson cases; weither it be a civil or criminal case, there is no acquiescence of evidence from the defense unless Justice Owen-Stinson is working in their behalf. Justice Owen-Stinson makes her rulings prior to trial with the Plaintiff or Defendant (whomever SHE represents). [Redacted by Editor] Furthermore, he has no Courtroom etiquette.

Following this forum I noticed negative rating's on Justice Owen-Stinson often get deleted such as a case against the NYPD in criminal court before Justice Owen-Stinson. That is no surprise; evidence also disappears in Justice Owen-Stinson cases or not allowed. Due process is OBSOLETE in Justice Owen-Stinson cases, replaced with sham hearings for the Party she is working with PRIOR to a trial. Justice Owen-Stinson should be disbarred and removed from the bench.

**REPOSTING MY COMMENT FOR THE THIRD TIME; THAT WAS DELETED**

Criminal Defense Lawyer

Comment #: NY7128
Rating:1.0
Comments:
Two words:

Crazy lady.

Civil Litigation - Private

Comment #: NY6549
Rating:2.0
Comments:
Justice Owen-Stinson is uninterested in the law and would prefer not to be bothered with a discussion of precedent or statute. Despite myriad citation to binding law on the issue before her, the Judge was uninterested in following the same. Was disrespectful to the moving counsel, rolling her eyes and making dismissive and disruptive gestures and noises while argument was ongoing. Shocked when attorney called her on it. Plainly biased pro defense and plainly unconcerned with following the law. Terrible judicial temperament.

Civil Litigation - Private

Comment #: NY5615
Rating:9.9
Comments:
Great and learned judge.

Litigant

Comment #: NY3800
Rating:1.0
Comments:
Un-Honorable Judge Betty Owen Stinson is one of the most despicable persons I have ever met, in my entire life on this earth. In my opinion she has no values or conscience, she is incompetent, she is vengeful, abuses her power, and creates havoc in our judicial system. In my opinion she actually is a disgrace to those honorable Judges that sit at the bench, and go by the law. From what I have seen of Ms. Stinson; she does not respect or go by the Constitution of the United States, and goes by her own rules. Apparently "due process" is not a word in her vocabulary, nor does she adhere to it. She appears to have no respect for anyone, including the law. She has been cited allegedly for misconduct in Florida, from my understanding by the Florida Bar. I believe she carried over the same behavior to the New York Courts. I honestly believe she had endangered at least one person’s life, by her erroneous, bias, unlawful if not illegal Orders/Judgments, and nothing but a criminal that has not paid her debt to society for her crimes. Until I met her, I have had respect and honored every person in our legal system. Quite honestly, there is only one Judge Stinson, and thank God we do not have more like her, making decisions in our Court Rooms. I am not sure if she just does not comprehend the law, she thinks she is above the law, [redacted] Hopefully, when her term ends in 2013, she will no longer cause any more pain, suffering, and hardships in her "victims" lives - and she can be replaced with another one of the honorable judges, that New York is proud to have presiding in our Court System.

Respectfully, one that had endured so very much pain and suffering due to this women and her sham hearing. Honestly I find it hard to believe she is behind the bench making any kind of decision. In my opinion, she is just not qualified to be behind the bench, in “any” Court room – [Redacted] And litigants deserve a fair hearing/trial. 09/25/2012